28 October 2022

Rishi Sunak: A New Leaf on the Conservative Oak?

Dazed. Weary. Unsurprised. Britain has a new Prime Minister. Again. 

Rishi Sunak is the UK’s first British Asian Prime Minister – unfortunately, that is about the only positive of his appointment.

Sunak was Chancellor of the Exchequer (Finance Minister) under Boris Johnson. In my opinion, anyone who actively supported Boris Johnson, a lying, law-breaking and anti-democratic Prime Minister, can be painted with the same brush.

As it happens, there is plenty of evidence to support that. As Chancellor, Sunak faced several scandals. First, the Greensill lobbying scandal saw Sunak send private texts to former Prime Minister David Cameron to help him access finance for his firm. Secondly, Suank’s multi-millionaire wife, Akshata Murty, has avoided paying tens of millions of pounds in taxes through her non-dom status. There was also speculation that Sunak himself had kept a US Green Card until October 2021 in order to gain tax advantages. Finally, Sunak was fined for attending a party during a COVID lockdown in 2021.

The fact that Rishi Sunak is the new Prime Minister shows that the Conservatives aren’t taking calls for renewal seriously. Sunak is just a slightly cleaner, more polished version of his former boss, but he has committed all the same infractions. What’s more, the composition of his new cabinet is much the same as Boris Johnson’s. Apparently, it doesn’t matter what you do when you are in government; you won’t be held accountable for it.

The most egregious example of this is Suella Braverman, who resigned from Liz Truss’ cabinet following a data breach. In her resignation letter, she wrote: “The business of government relies upon people accepting responsibility for their mistakes. Pretending we haven't made mistakes, carrying on as if everyone can't see that we have made them, and hoping that things will magically come right is not serious politics.” Now, just a week later, she is back in the cabinet.

To illustrate my point, in this table I list the top cabinet positions, whether their occupants were in Boris Johnson or Liz Truss’ cabinets, and any blemishes to their reputation.

MP

Current Position

Truss’ Cabinet

Johnson’s Cabinet

Infractions & Scandals

Rishi Sunak

Prime Minister


X

Wife’s tax affairs; corruption; partygate fine

Dominic Raab

Justice Secretary and Deputy Prime Minister


X

Criticised for handling of Afghanistan crisis (on holiday)

Jeremy Hunt

Chancellor

X


Minister of Health during times of intense austerity

Suella Braverman

Home Secretary

X

X

Resigned from LT’s cabinet last week over a data breach

James Cleverly

Foreign Secretary

X

X


Ben Wallace

Defence Secretary

X

X


Nadhim Zahawi

Minister Without Portfolio

X

X

One of the richest politicians in the Commons; submitted expenses to pay for his stables

Oliver Dowden

Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster


X


Therese Coffey

Environment Secretary

X

X


Grant Shapps

Business Secretary

X

X

Resigned from cabinet following allegations he ignored warnings about bullying

Penny Mordaunt

Leader of the Commons


X


Mel Stride

Work & Pensions Secretary




Gillian Keegan

Education Secretary

X

X

Husband’s firm received government contracts during the pandemic; met with bereaved parents whilst COVID-positive

Steve Barclay

Health Secretary


X


Mark Harper

Transport Secretary



Resigned as Immigration Minister in 2014 after it was revealed that his cleaner did not have permission to work in the UK

Michael Gove

Levelling Up Secretary


X


Kemi Badenoch

International Trade Secretary

X

X


Michelle Donelan

Culture Secretary

X

X

Partner’s firm received government contracts during the pandemic

Simon Hart

Chief Whip


X


Robert Jenrick

Immigration Minister

X

X

Corruption; attended Trump’s inauguration

Gavin Williamson

Minister Without Portfolio


X

Sacked after leaking national security information to Huawei, and again due to failures as Education Secretary during the pandemic


With that in mind, let’s see what Sunak had to say in his opening speech as Prime Minister.

"It is only right to explain why I'm standing here as your new Prime Minister.

Agreed – he is the fourth consecutive Prime Minister to enter office through an internal Conservative leadership election.

"Right now, our country is facing a profound economic crisis. The aftermath of Covid still lingers.

Sunak was Chancellor during the entire pandemic.

"[…] I want to pay tribute to my predecessor Liz Truss. She was not wrong to want to improve growth in this country. It is a noble aim, and I admired her restlessness to create change. But some mistakes were made, not borne of ill will or bad intentions - quite the opposite in fact.

Isn’t it a Conservative Party rule that your economic policies have to have at least a bit of ill will towards the poor?

"[...] I will place economic stability and confidence at the heart of this government's agenda. This will mean difficult decisions to come.

Whenever a politician says that there are “difficult decisions to come”, they mean that some people are not going to be happy. When a Conservative says that, they mean that the poor will starve or freeze or likely both.

"[…] But I promise you this, I will bring that same compassion to the challenges we face today.

Ah yes, the compassion of a man who presided over lockdowns which prevented families from visiting their dying relatives in hospital, all the while having a party with his mates on Downing Street.

"[...] I will unite our country - not with words, but with action.

Pass.

"I will work day in and day out to deliver for you.

Yup.

"This government will have integrity, professionalism and accountability at every level.

A man whose reputation has been mired by a corruption scandal surely can't talk about “integrity”. A man who protected Boris Johnson and supported him in his lies for years cannot talk about "accountability". A man who broke the law as Chancellor cannot talk about "professionalism".

"Trust is earned and I will earn yours.

Oh, I think it’s a bit late for that.

"I will always be grateful to Boris Johnson for his incredible achievements as prime minister, and I treasure his warmth and generosity of spirit.

Do I even need to explain this one?

"And I know he would agree that the mandate my party earned in 2019 is not the sole property of any one individual. It is a mandate that belongs to, and unites, all of us.

Here it is, the classic line where he tries to convince us that he isn’t going to call a general election, not because his party would lose, but because Boris Johnson’s mandate apparently extends to three different Prime Ministers with different policies.

"And the heart of that mandate is our manifesto. I will deliver on its promise. A stronger NHS, better schools, safer streets, control of our borders, protecting our environment, supporting our armed forces, levelling up and building an economy that embraces the opportunities of Brexit where businesses invest, innovate and create jobs.

Ha for a second there I thought he might be serious. The NHS is weak because the Conservatives have drained it of resources. The streets are dangerous because the Conservatives cut the police force. Our environmental policy is a disaster because Sunak’s precious manifesto was ranked the worst in terms of combatting climate change. The economy is weak (at least partly) because the Conservatives stripped us of our biggest trading partner and reduced all confidence in the pound. And, obviously, Brexit brings no opportunities.

"[…] I fully appreciate how hard things are.

I’m not sure that a multi-millionaire (valued at £730 million), who himself admitted he didn’t have working-class friends, can understand that.

"And I understand too that I have work to do to restore trust after all that has happened. All I can say is that I am not daunted.

Actually, you can say "sorry".

"I know the high office I have accepted and I hope to live up to its demands. But when the opportunity to serve comes along, you cannot question the moment, only your willingness.

Sure you can. You can question whether you have any of the qualities of a decent human being.

"So I stand here before you, ready to lead our country into the future, to put your needs above politics, to reach out and build a government that represents the very best traditions of my party.

Name one of the “best traditions” of the Conservative Party. Corruption? Sleaze? Scandal? I will wait.

"Together we can achieve incredible things.

“We”? Don’t bring me into this.

"We will create a future worthy of the sacrifices so many have made, and fill tomorrow and every day thereafter with hope. Thank you."

My only hope is for the next general election.

 


Ecological Defilement - How a new trainline is carving up the British countryside

When I was 11, my English teacher gave us all a newspaper clipping to teach us about persuasive writing. The article was about High Speed 2 ...